Frequently asked questions about Probate in New York

What Is Probate in New York?

Probate is the legal process through which a New York Surrogate’s Court determines whether a document is the valid Last Will and Testament of the person who died. When the court is satisfied that the will is legally valid, it can admit the will to probate and appoint the executor nominated in the will. The executor then receives legal authority to administer the probate estate and carry out the terms of the will. Probate should be distinguished from estate administration more broadly. Probate establishes the will and the executor’s authority. The work of collecting assets, paying debts and taxes, handling claims, accounting, and making distributions continues after the probate proceeding begins.

​

When Is Probate Required in New York?

Probate is generally relevant when a person dies with a will and owns property that must pass through the probate estate. Whether probate is actually necessary depends on the assets the person owned and how those assets were titled.

For example, if significant property was owned solely in the decedent’s name and does not pass through a beneficiary designation, joint ownership arrangement, trust, or another non-probate mechanism, a probate proceeding may be necessary to give the executor authority to deal with those assets.

Not every person who dies with a will necessarily requires a full probate proceeding. A qualifying small estate may instead use New York’s voluntary administration procedure.

​

What Assets Go Through Probate?

Probate generally concerns assets owned in the decedent’s individual name that do not pass automatically through another legal arrangement.

Examples may include:

• Individually owned bank accounts

• Individually owned investment accounts

• Real estate titled solely in the decedent’s name

• Personal property

• Business interests owned individually

• Other assets without an effective beneficiary or survivorship arrangement

The important question is not simply what kind of asset it is, but how it was owned and whether another valid transfer mechanism applies at death.

​

What Assets Usually Do Not Go Through Probate?

Some assets may pass outside probate because they are governed by another form of ownership or transfer.

Depending on the circumstances, examples can include:

• Property owned jointly with rights of survivorship

• Accounts with valid payable-on-death or transfer-on-death designations

• Life insurance payable to a named beneficiary

• Retirement accounts with valid beneficiary designations

• Assets properly held in a lifetime trust

That is why a will does not necessarily control everything a person owns.

Beneficiary designations, account ownership, trusts, and the will should be coordinated as part of the overall estate plan.

​

Where Is Probate Filed in New York?

A probate proceeding is generally filed in the Surrogate’s Court of the county where the person who died was domiciled at the time of death. Domicile generally refers to the person’s primary legal residence.

The nominated executor typically files the original will, a certified death certificate, a probate petition, and other supporting documents with the appropriate Surrogate’s Court.

​

Who Files for Probate?

The person nominated as executor in the will generally begins the probate proceeding.

If that person has died, is unable to serve, declines to serve, or is otherwise unavailable, the will may nominate a successor executor. New York law also provides procedures for circumstances in which the named executor cannot or does not qualify. Simply being named as executor in a will does not give someone immediate authority to collect or distribute estate assets. Court appointment is generally required before the executor has authority to act as fiduciary for the probate estate.

​

What Documents Are Usually Needed to Start Probate?

The exact filing requirements depend on the estate and the Surrogate’s Court, but a probate filing generally includes:

• The original will

• A certified death certificate

• A probate petition

• Information about the decedent’s distributees

• Information concerning the estate and its assets

• Other supporting affidavits, waivers, consents, or documents required by the circumstances

The decedent’s distributees—people who would inherit under New York intestacy law if there were no valid will—must be identified even if the will leaves property to different beneficiaries.

Depending on the circumstances, distributees may receive a citation or may sign waivers and consents.

​

What Are Letters Testamentary?

Letters Testamentary are court-issued documents that evidence the executor’s authority to act on behalf of the estate.

Once the court admits the will to probate and appoints the executor, Letters Testamentary can be issued.

Banks, financial institutions, title companies, and other parties may request certified evidence of those Letters before allowing the executor to collect, transfer, sell, or otherwise manage estate property.

Being named executor in the will and actually receiving authority from the court are therefore two separate steps.

​

What Does an Executor Do During Probate?

An executor is a fiduciary responsible for administering the estate according to the will and applicable law.

Depending on the estate, responsibilities can include:

• Identifying and collecting probate assets

• Protecting estate property

• Opening an estate account

• Addressing valid debts and expenses

• Handling creditor claims

• Filing required tax returns

• Managing or selling estate property when appropriate

• Maintaining financial records

• Communicating with beneficiaries

• Making appropriate distributions

• Providing an accounting when required

An executor has fiduciary duties to the estate and its interested parties and should not treat estate property as personal property.

​​

If you are an executor and need guidance, we offer help. More information can be found on our Executor & Administrator Guidance page.

​

How Long Does Probate Take in New York?

There is no single fixed probate timeline. The time needed depends on the county, court workload, whether required parties cooperate, whether heirs must be located or served, whether the will is contested, and whether questions arise about the validity of the will or the executor’s appointment. A straightforward uncontested probate proceeding may move much more quickly than an estate involving missing heirs, disputed documents, litigation, complicated assets, tax issues, or family conflict. It is also important to distinguish getting the will admitted to probate from fully completing the estate administration. Even after Letters Testamentary are issued, the executor may still need substantial time to collect property, address debts and taxes, sell assets, account, and make final distributions. New York law also gives special significance to a seven-month period following the issuance of letters in connection with creditor claims and fiduciary protection for good-faith distributions.

​

How Much Does Probate Cost in New York?

Probate costs vary based on the size and complexity of the estate.

Potential expenses may include:

• Surrogate’s Court filing fees

• Attorney fees

• Executor commissions

• Accounting or tax-preparation fees

• Appraisals

• Property expenses

• Bond premiums where applicable

• Costs associated with litigation or contested matters

New York Surrogate’s Court filing fees are generally based on the value of the estate involved in the proceeding.

Attorney fees are not set by a single statewide probate fee schedule and can vary significantly depending on the work required.

​

What Happens If Someone Dies Without a Will?

Technically, a person who dies without a valid will does not go through probate of a will.

Instead, an administration proceeding may be filed in Surrogate’s Court.

In an administration proceeding, the court appoints an administrator rather than an executor. Property subject to intestacy is distributed according to New York’s intestate succession laws rather than according to the terms of a will.

The executor/administrator distinction can be summarized as:

• Will → Probate → Executor

• No Will → Administration → Administrator

​

What Is a Small Estate in New York?

New York provides a simplified proceeding called Voluntary Administration, commonly referred to as a small-estate proceeding. Under current New York law, a small estate generally involves personal property with a gross value of $50,000 or less, excluding certain property specified by law. The procedure may be available whether or not the person left a will. However, the small-estate procedure has important limitations. It generally does not provide authority to administer real property owned by the decedent in New York, and certain circumstances may require a different proceeding. The $50,000 threshold generally concerns qualifying personal property, not simply the total economic value of everything connected to the decedent.

​

What Happens If the Decedent Owned Real Estate?

How real estate is handled depends on how it was titled and the overall estate circumstances.

Real estate owned solely in the decedent’s name can create a need for a probate or administration proceeding, particularly where a fiduciary must obtain authority concerning the property.

Jointly owned real estate may pass differently depending on the form of ownership.

Real property also matters when evaluating whether the simplified small-estate procedure is appropriate.

Because ownership language on the deed can materially affect what happens after death, the deed itself should be reviewed rather than making assumptions based solely on the fact that the decedent “owned a house.”

​

Do Beneficiaries Have to Be Notified About Probate?

Interested parties generally receive notice of the probate proceeding as required by New York law.

The probate petition identifies the decedent’s distributees. Certain interested persons may be asked to sign a waiver and consent or may be served with a citation. Beneficiaries named in the will are also entitled to notice in accordance with applicable probate procedures. Notice allows interested parties to know that the will is being offered for probate and gives those with legal standing an opportunity to assert appropriate rights.

​

Can Someone Object to Probate?

Yes.

​

A person with the necessary legal interest may be able to object to the admission of a will to probate.

New York’s Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act provides procedures for filing objections to probate, and contested probate matters can involve discovery, examination of witnesses, motion practice, settlement negotiations, and potentially trial.

The fact that someone is unhappy with the terms of a will does not by itself mean there is a valid legal basis to defeat probate.

​

What Are Common Grounds for Contesting a Will?

Will contests can involve issues such as:

• Lack of testamentary capacity

• Undue influence

• Fraud

• Improper execution

• Forgery

• Questions concerning revocation

• Whether the document offered is actually the decedent’s last valid will

The applicable legal standards are fact-specific.

A will contest is substantially different from routine uncontested probate and generally deserves separate treatment as an estate-litigation matter.

​

Can Probate Be Avoided?

Some assets can be structured to pass outside probate.

Strategies can include appropriate use of:

• Lifetime trusts

• Beneficiary designations

• Joint ownership

• Payable-on-death or transfer-on-death arrangements

• Other estate-planning techniques appropriate to the asset

But probate avoidance should not be treated as an end in itself. The best estate plan depends on the person’s family, assets, tax considerations, creditor issues, long-term-care concerns, beneficiary needs, and planning objectives.

A strategy that avoids probate but creates tax, control, beneficiary, or ownership problems is not necessarily a better estate plan.

​

Does Having a Will Avoid Probate?

No.

​

A will does not avoid probate. In fact, probate is the process through which the Surrogate’s Court determines whether the will is valid and appoints the executor. A properly drafted will can make the estate process clearer by identifying beneficiaries, nominating an executor, and expressing the decedent’s wishes, but probate may still be necessary for assets passing under the will.

​

When Can Beneficiaries Receive Their Inheritance?

There is no universal date by which an executor must distribute every estate. Before making final distributions, the executor generally needs to understand the estate’s assets, debts, administration expenses, tax obligations, claims, and other potential liabilities. New York law also provides a seven-month period following issuance of letters that is important in determining a fiduciary’s potential liability regarding later-presented creditor claims. In appropriate circumstances, an executor may make partial distributions before every aspect of the estate is complete, but sufficient assets should generally be retained to address anticipated obligations. Whether an early distribution is appropriate depends on the particular estate.

​

Can an Executor Get Paid in New York?

Yes.

​

New York law generally allows executors and other qualifying fiduciaries to receive statutory commissions for their services. Under SCPA § 2307, commissions are calculated under a graduated statutory schedule based principally on property received and paid out by the fiduciary, subject to specific rules and exceptions. Executor commissions are separate from reimbursement of legitimate estate expenses. If an attorney serves both as executor and as attorney for the estate, additional statutory disclosure and compensation rules may apply.

​

Does the Executor Have to Provide an Accounting?

Executors must maintain appropriate records concerning estate administration.

An estate accounting generally shows property received, income, expenses, debts, distributions, and remaining assets.

Not every estate requires a formal judicial accounting. Many estates are concluded informally when the interested parties receive appropriate information and agree to the proposed distributions.

When disputes arise or interested parties require court review, a formal accounting proceeding may become necessary.

​

Do You Need an Attorney for Probate in New York?

New York does not impose a universal rule that every probate proceeding must be handled by an attorney.

However, probate can involve procedural, fiduciary, tax, title, creditor, beneficiary, and litigation issues.

Legal assistance may be particularly important when:

• The will may be contested

• Heirs are difficult to locate

• Family members disagree

• The estate owns substantial or unusual assets

• Real estate must be handled

• Tax issues are significant

• Creditor disputes arise

• Fiduciary conduct is questioned

• The executor is uncertain about legal responsibilities

​​

Sources & Legal References

New York State Unified Court System — Probate: When a Person Dies With a Will

https://www.nycourts.gov/help/when-someone-dies/probate-when-person-dies-will

New York State Unified Court System — Fiduciary of an Estate

https://www.nycourts.gov/help/when-someone-dies/fiduciary-estate

New York State Unified Court System — Small Estate: When a Person Dies With Less Than $50,000

https://www.nycourts.gov/help/when-someone-dies/small-estate-when-person-dies-less-50000

New York State Unified Court System — Administration: When a Person Dies With No Will

https://www.nycourts.gov/help/when-someone-dies/administration-when-person-dies-no-will

New York Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act, Article 14 — Probate Proceedings, Construction of Wills and Related Matters

https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/SCP/A14

New York Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act § 1301 — Small Estate Definitions

https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/SCP/1301

New York Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act § 1802 — Effect of Failure to Present a Claim Within Seven Months

https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/SCP/1802

New York Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act § 2307 — Executor and Fiduciary Commissions

https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/SCP/2307